Prerequisite Knowledge:

  • individuals with certain traits in particular environments are more likely than others to survive and have offspring
  • whether a characteristic is considered advantageous or disadvantageous depends on the environment (when the environment changes, the advantageous or disadvantageous characteristics can also change)
  • a population is a group of individuals that belong to the same species, live in the same area, and breed with others in the group
  • a species is a group of organisms that look alike and are capable of producing fertile offspring in nature
  • biodiversity is the variety of species living within an ecosystem
  • mutation, crossing over, and independent assortment are the mechanisms by which genetic variation is created at the molecular level

Translating Standards into Learning Goals (The “Unpacking”):

  • students should be able to make this key association: individuals that have physical or behavioral traits that better suit their environment are more likely to survive and reproduce than those that do not have such traits
  • students should be able to explain what is meant by “differential reproductive success” between organisms as the difference between how many offspring individuals are able to leave behind.
  • students should be able to recognize that an individual with higher reproductive success leaves behind more of its traits in the next generation
  • students should be able to list the following conditions under which NS is made possible: 1) genetic variation of offspring due to sexual reproduction, 2) the environment having a limited supply of resources that cannot possibly sustain all the offspring that are produced by every individual, and 3) differential reproductive success
  • students should identify NS as the process by which evolution occurs
  • students should be able to explain why it doesn’t make sense to say “NS acts on populations” but it makes sense to say “NS acts on individuals”
  • students should be able to explain why it doesn’t make sense to say “an individual has evolved” but it makes sense to say “a population has evolved”
  • students should be able to explain that mutation, crossing over, and independent assortment are three genetic mechanisms that lead to new gene combinations
  • students should recognize that new gene combinations amount to different traits found among individuals in a population
  • students should recognize that new traits may be advantageous or disadvantageous depending on the environment they are found in
  • students should be able to give an example of an environmental condition and traits that would be advantageous and traits that would be disadvantageous in this condition
  • students should be able to name a trait that would be advantageous in one environment and disadvantageous in another.
  • students should be able to define divergence as the accumulation of differences between groups
  • students should be able to define speciation as the formation of new species
  • students should be able to recognize that increasing divergence leads to speciation
  • students should be able to recognize that NS brings about divergence
  • students should recognize that organisms which are geographically isolated are essentially no longer able to reproduce with one another and therefore create viable offspring.
  • species become extinct when the environment changes and characteristics of a species are not enough to allow them to survive
  • most species that have lived on Earth have become extinct (i.e. extinction common)
  • the fossil record is evidence of extinction and speciation over eons of time.
  • students should be able to explain how humans can genetically engineer organisms for new traits

Some Big Student Misconceptions:


  • an individual can evolve we must warn them that only populations can be said to evolve
  • Natural Selection is goal-directed, for example: bats developed wings because they “wanted” or “needed” them. BUT we must warn them that need does NOT direct change! Otherwise, how would extinction be so common?
  • changes are induced by the environment and that the mutations which arise depend on the selection pressures present, they may use the following reasoning: “because the environment favored such and such trait, mutants arose in the population that had such and such trait
  • Lamarckian notion of inheritance of acquired traits, i.e. the “use and disuse” notion, they may reason like so: “because snakes didn’t use their legs much and they did use their tongues more, over time they lost their legs and their tongues became longer”



*Please note I used already "unpacked" learning goals from here